In New York City in 2018, a cat reportedly fell from the window of a Thirty second-floor residence onto laborious asphalt—and survived. After a two-day keep on the vet, who handled a collapsed lung and damaged tooth, the four-legged pal was capable of return house. It’s seemingly that different related conditions have given rise to the adage that cats have 9 lives. For many years, researchers from a variety of disciplines have been making an attempt to know their superb survival abilities.
But it was not the animals’ falls from dizzying heights that first puzzled physicists within the late nineteenth century. Instead consultants have been stumped by images of cats spinning on their very own axis whereas falling after which touchdown on their toes. Images from that point present an individual holding a cat by its legs in order that its again is dealing with the bottom. Then the animal is launched. At first, the feline floats the other way up within the air with its again dealing with the bottom. But within the subsequent photographs, one thing occurs that appears to defy the legal guidelines of physics: the cat turns and lands on its paws.
Of course, individuals knew from on a regular basis observations that these quadrupeds can flip within the air. But it had been assumed that they receive the momentum obligatory for this motion by pushing off from the floor from which they fall. That’s as a result of in keeping with the conservation of angular momentum, it’s not possible for an object that’s not spinning to immediately rotate with out exterior affect. Yet that’s precisely what the pictures present. Initially the cat falls straight down. Then it manages to rotate by itself axis. How is that doable?
This phenomenon occupied many scientists, together with physicist James Clerk Maxwell, identified for his work on electromagnetism. He performed a number of experiments wherein he dropped cats from numerous heights (together with from open home windows) and onto beds and tables. But it wasn’t till 1969 that the “falling cat downside” was solved. As it turned out, the cat’s physique had not been thought-about rigorously sufficient. It will not be merely a cylindrical object that magically begins to spin. If you look intently, you possibly can see {that a} cat’s higher and decrease physique rotate in reverse instructions. Thus, conservation of angular momentum is preserved. If the animal rotates like a pepper mill in two completely different instructions, the change in angular momentum is zero.
But how does a cat handle to land on its paws? To do that, felines exploit the bodily legal guidelines of classical mechanics: by inserting their entrance paws near their physique, they cut back their second of inertia. Like determine skaters, their higher physique rotates shortly round its personal axis. With their hind legs, the animals then make use of the other impact. They stretch their legs to create as massive a second of inertia as doable. As a end result, the higher physique rotates by means of a big angle, whereas the legs rotate much less in the other way. The animals’ extraordinarily versatile backbone makes this motion doable. Once the higher physique is now within the appropriate place (i.e., head aligned upright above the bottom), cats can prolong their entrance paws, tighten their hind legs and carry out the pepper-mill-like motion in the other way in order that their hind paws are additionally aligned above the bottom. In this manner, the animals all the time handle to land on all fours—following all of the legal guidelines of physics.
How High Can Cats Fall and Survive?
The legal guidelines of physics state that the upper the autumn, the more durable the influence. But a research from the Nineteen Eighties paints a unique image—not less than for cats. Two New York City veterinarians described a complete of 132 circumstances between June and November 1984 wherein cats had fallen from as excessive because the Thirty second flooring of high-rise buildings. Overall, 90 p.c of the cats survived. When the veterinarians documented the accidents, they made an astonishing remark: whereas the severity of the injury elevated as much as a peak of about seven tales, it appeared to lower thereafter. In different phrases, a fall from the eleventh flooring may finish extra gently for a cat than one from the sixth flooring.
Once once more, the felines appeared to interrupt the legal guidelines of physics. The greater the ground from which a physique falls, the longer it’s accelerated by Earth’s gravity. Thus, its velocity ought to improve increasingly till it lastly hits the bottom. The abrupt influence converts the animal’s kinetic vitality from falling into different types of vitality, which may result in damaged bones, collapsed lungs, and worse. Thus, falling from excessive flooring ought to have extra disagreeable penalties than from low flooring.
But this mind-set in regards to the feline free-fall ignores air resistance. After all, cats don’t fall to the bottom in a vacuum however transfer by means of air that may gradual their fall. Thus, two opposing forces act on a cat throughout a fall: the gravitational pressure Fg and the frictional pressure FR, which slows it down. While Fg has a quite simple kind and is merely the product of the mass m of the cat and the acceleration brought on by gravity g, the air resistance relies on the cross-sectional space A, the drag coefficient cW, the air density ρ and the speed v of the falling object: FR = ½ x ρ x A x cW x v2. At the start of the autumn, the cat has a velocity of zero, so solely the acceleration brought on by gravity acts on it, however as v will increase, the other frictional pressure then makes itself felt. Thus, to find out the concrete movement of the animal, one should calculate the whole pressure (Fg – FR). This then determines which acceleration acts on a cat of a sure weight m: m x a = Fg – FR.
A Speed Limit for Falling Felines
The acceleration corresponds to the change in velocity, which could be expressed mathematically by a spinoff, a = d⁄dt v. So if you wish to calculate the velocity of the cat at a sure time, it’s a must to resolve an advanced system of equations containing each the velocity itself and its spinoff (acceleration): m x d⁄dtv = m x g −½ x ρ x A x cW x v2. For such differential equations, there may be typically no precise resolution. In this case, it’s doable to calculate an answer for the speed akin to a hyperbolic tangent. Depending on the cross-section and weight of the cat, you find yourself with a curve that grows quickly firstly after which flattens out and converges to a relentless worth: the animal positive aspects velocity shortly firstly of the autumn earlier than the air resistance ultimately turns into so sturdy that it now not quickens, as physicist Rhett Allain of Southeastern Louisiana University calculated for Wired.
.png)
You can even calculate this terminal velocity, or higher velocity restrict, fairly simply. Because the terminal velocity outcomes when the frictional pressure is strictly as massive because the gravitational pressure on this case, the 2 forces cancel one another out and a falling object plummets in the direction of the bottom with fixed velocity. So you simply have to unravel the equation m x g = ½ ρ A cW v2 for v, and also you get: v = √(2mg⁄ρAc).
To give a selected worth for the terminal velocity of a cat, one want solely insert numerical values for the variables. While one can estimate the load and cross-sectional space of a cat, the drag coefficient is harder to find out. Suppose a cat weighs 4 kilograms (about 8.8 kilos), is 50 centimeters (round 19 inches) lengthy and 15 centimeters (almost 6 inches) extensive. These measurements would give the animal a cross-sectional space of A = 0.075 sq. meters. The cat may even have the drag coefficient of a cylinder (cW = 0.8). Then the ultimate velocity of the animal is: v = 32.68 meters per second, which corresponds to simply beneath 120 kilometers (or 74.5 miles) per hour.
To discover out at what peak a cat reaches this terminal velocity, one can resolve the differential equation and thus calculate the speed on the time of influence as a perform of the peak of the autumn.
.png)
As could be seen from the graph, cats already attain a velocity of 30 meters per second at a fall peak of 100 meters. Because cats have already been noticed to outlive falls from greater buildings (akin to from the Thirty second flooring), they’ll theoretically survive an influence with the best doable terminal velocity of 120 kilometers per hour. Consequently, the animals may, in idea, survive a fall from any conceivable peak.
Actual Effect or Survivorship Bias?
But this terminal velocity calculation doesn’t clarify the observations of the New York veterinarians: Why do cats appear to outlive a fall from the seventh flooring or greater higher than from decrease flooring? One rationalization includes the animals’ expertise.
When a cat falls from a low peak, it’s weightless for a short while. Instinctively, due to this fact, it can prolong its legs beneath it to land on all fours. At excessive fall heights, nonetheless, this technique will not be helpful: aligned legs can result in severe harm as a result of the animal’s weight is distributed awkwardly. This distinction could clarify why the survival fee decreases with rising peak—not less than as much as the seventh flooring. But at better fall heights, the frictional pressure turns into noticeable through the fall. That’s why, the veterinarians speculate, the cat now not has the feeling of falling. Thus, it will probably calm down and won’t stretch its legs. It lands extra gently, with a extra even weight distribution and, due to this fact, higher possibilities of survival.
But there may be additionally an easier rationalization for the remark—albeit a extra miserable one for animal lovers. The veterinarians’ findings may mirror the so-called survivorship bias. If a cat falls from a excessive flooring and dies immediately, the proprietor in all probability gained’t hassle to cease by a veterinary clinic. Therefore, the variety of unreported deaths might be greater than what has been recorded by medical professionals.
This article initially appeared in Spektrum der Wissenschaft and was reproduced with permission.
