I’ve used many of the handheld gaming PCs which have launched this 12 months, however I at all times return to my Steam Deck. It’s not essentially the most highly effective, it has some quirks, and I nonetheless battle with a irritating bug that may drain the battery in minutes. But it’s nonetheless the finest handheld gaming PC you should purchase, and that’s due largely to the truth that it doesn’t run on Windows like different handhelds.
It’s not that I don’t like Windows. As a PC {hardware} nerd, I’m nicely conscious of each the advantages and idiosyncrasies of PC gaming. Things don’t at all times work the way in which you count on them to, and that’s simply a part of the method to get the perfect gaming expertise potential. When it involves this evolving type issue of handheld gaming PCs, nevertheless, these points are amplified and pushed to their breaking level.
We’ve been right here earlier than
When it comes right down to it, the issue with Windows-based handhelds is easy: you’ll be able to’t take a desktop working system and power it onto a handheld. For as versatile as Windows is, it presents a slew of points for handheld PCs. Overlays battle with one another, any administration choices are restricted to a tiny touchscreen, and fashionable comforts like suspending a recreation aren’t even a thought. We want a devoted model of Windows for a majority of these handhelds, however Microsoft doesn’t have an important monitor report on that entrance.
Microsoft has tried to make a “lite” model of Windows for many years. That’s not an exaggeration. Attempts at a cell model of Windows date again to 2000 with Pocket PC, and since then, we’ve seen varied types of Windows for tablets and cell. For essentially the most half, these variations solely noticed a few releases on just a few area of interest gadgets earlier than dying out completely.
The newest instance of Microsoft’s makes an attempt is the ill-fated Windows 10X. This light-weight model of Windows 10 was alleged to launch for dual-screen tablets, but it surely was canceled in 2021. Some options labored their means into Windows 10, and we are able to see remnants of the replace in Windows 11’s enhanced pill mode on gadgets just like the Surface Laptop Studio 2.
Even with glimmers of a stripped-down model of Windows, we haven’t seen Microsoft do it efficiently durin g its many years of makes an attempt. I’ve little question that Microsoft will proceed to iterate, and we would someday get the lite model of Windows that Microsoft has promised for years. Still, we’re gone the purpose of ready for that to occur, and it’s time to maneuver on.
There is one space the place Microsoft has efficiently tailored Windows to a different type issue, although, and that’s Xbox. Microsoft initially based mostly its Xbox System Software on Windows 8 with the discharge of the Xbox One earlier than transferring on to Windows 10 Core just a few years later. This core working system was the premise for a number of different variations of Windows, together with variations for HoloLens and the Surface Hub.
This alone reveals that Microsoft can make an adaptable OS that may match into a number of type elements. For handheld gaming PCs, although, we simply don’t have a particular model. Instead, gadgets just like the Asus ROG Ally, Lenovo Legion Go, and Ayaneo 2S are pushing forward with a desktop model of Windows 11 that doesn’t match the aim of those gadgets — and that’s the place the issues stem from.
But wait, there’s extra
If Microsoft could make a stripped-down model of Windows for handheld gaming PCs, why don’t we’ve it? Microsoft actually tried to deliver Windows to each system with its preliminary Xbox push, however evidently effort has all however died after a string of {hardware} failures.
Windows Core was constructed round Universal Windows Platform (UWP) apps. This format allowed builders to ship apps to all variations of Windows, together with these working on Xbox, with a single file. It was the constructing block for one thing nice: an ecosystem of Windows that works throughout gadgets with the identical apps. Microsoft has slowly dismantled this ecosystem over the previous a number of years, although.
Windows Phone died out, the formidable HoloLens challenge shifted to a sole enterprise focus, and UWP apps on PC slowly pale away on account of Microsoft shutting down its advert platform for UWP. Now, we’re in a spot the place Microsoft nonetheless helps some UWP apps, however the a lot bigger pool of video games accessible on Windows are conventional Win32 apps.
The unique thought behind a core model of Windows would have allowed Microsoft to rapidly adapt a brand new model to meet the wants of the rising marketplace for handheld gaming PCs. With the mishmash of options and assist we’ve now, although, it’s no surprise that almost all gadgets go for the total desktop model of Windows 11 as an alternative. At the very least, you’ll be able to be sure that most video games will run on the system with out points. It’s a laptop computer, simply with a controller as an alternative of a keyboard and trackpad.
That distinction couldn’t be extra essential. Windows 11 works on handhelds just like the ROG Ally, and that’s a feat alone. But there’s one system that actually understands the significance of software program for this rising type issue: the Steam Deck.
There’s a solution
There’s one other platform that’s extremely modular and adaptable to totally different type elements: Linux. From good gadgets to full desktops to Android, the premise of so many alternative gadgets is Linux. That flexibility makes it an ideal companion for handheld gaming PCs.
That’s doubtless why Valve selected to make use of its personal SteamOS as an alternative of Windows on the Steam Deck. This isn’t a completely new working system developed by Valve; SteamOS 3 relies on Arch Linux, which is a well-liked distribution of Linux. It additionally bundles Valve’s Proton compatibility layer to get Windows apps working on Linux. This, too, relies on the present Wine software for Linux.
Valve didn’t get SteamOS proper instantly. Original variations had been restricted in options and confirmed worse efficiency in comparison with native Windows apps. Now, nevertheless, SteamOS 3 can’t solely match Windows within the overwhelming majority of video games, however it will probably even exceed Windows in some circumstances. We’ve seen that with the Steam Deck and ROG Ally, the place the ROG Ally’s efficiency doesn’t scale in the way in which its {hardware} benefit would recommend.
There are limitations of Valve’s strategy, with third-party storefronts not at all times working and video games with anti-cheat software program refusing to run. However, there’s sufficient assist. Unlike Microsoft’s strategy with the Windows Core, Valve has a strong ecosystem of software program and options already constructed into Steam. Those got here earlier than SteamOS 3, not the opposite means round.
There are some clear benefits to Valve’s strategy, too. For starters, you’re capable of correctly droop the system whereas taking part in a recreation. That’s large for handheld gaming, and it’s a facet of gadgets just like the ROG Ally and Ayaneo 2S that’s nearly universally glossed over. In addition, you have got a single dwelling base for the software program. On Windows-based gadgets, you have got a string of utilities and overlays that may battle with one another, with every preventing for a high slot on the display screen.
Even after spending an hour with a tool just like the ROG Ally, the benefit of a purpose-built handheld working system turns into clear. That’s why the Steam Deck has a lot endurance, and the way it stays such a well-liked system even when sooner gadgets — just like the ROG Ally — can be found for an inexpensive worth.
Master of none
The quantity of software program accessible for Windows in unmatched, which is the most important power of the working system and likewise its greatest weak spot. Microsoft must cater to the various other ways folks use Windows, which suggests gadgets devoted to a specific sort of customers (i.e., players) usually don’t get the entire consideration they deserve.
I’m nonetheless hopeful we’ll see a stripped-back model of Windows 11 sooner or later that may make gadgets just like the ROG Ally stand above the Steam Deck. I’d fortunately bounce ship. For now, although, builders want a technique to cater to a particular sort of consumer, and that means is Linux, not Windows.
Editors’ Recommendations
